Risk Overall Project: Strategies for Threats and Opportunities
PMBOK v8 Definition
Overall project risk represents the effect of uncertainty on the project as a whole, arising from the combination of individual project risks and other sources of uncertainty. The risk thresholds for the project may be modified with the agreement of key stakeholders in order to embrace an opportunity, or strategies may be applied to bring the risk level back within agreed-upon thresholds.
Why It Matters for the Exam
This concept appears frequently in PMI exam questions about risk response planning and stakeholder engagement. You will encounter it in situational questions where the project has high overall risk—either positive or negative—and you must select the correct strategy to address the project-level risk exposure.
Key Points to Remember (for the exam)
- Two Dimensions: Overall project risk can be negative (threat) or positive (opportunity), requiring different response strategies for each.
- Threshold Modification: Risk thresholds may be modified with key stakeholder agreement to embrace an opportunity—this is a legitimate strategy, not a failure.
- Avoid Strategy: Used when overall risk is significantly negative and outside thresholds; may include removing high-risk scope or canceling the project (most extreme avoidance).
- Exploit Strategy: Used when overall risk is significantly positive and outside thresholds; includes adding high-benefit scope or modifying thresholds to capture the opportunity.
- Transfer/Share: For negative overall risk, transfer (paying a risk premium); for positive overall risk, share ownership to reap benefits. Examples: joint ventures, special-purpose companies, subcontracting.
- Mitigate/Enhance: Mitigate for negative overall risk; enhance for positive overall risk. These strategies change the level of overall project risk to optimize achieving objectives.
- Stakeholder Risk Appetite: Recorded in the risk management plan as measurable risk thresholds around each project objective, determining acceptable overall project risk exposure.
Typical PMI Exam Example
A construction project has an overall risk level significantly exceeding the agreed-upon thresholds due to geological uncertainty. The project manager recommends removing the high-risk excavation scope and focusing on less risky structures. The stakeholders agree. Which overall project risk strategy is being applied?
Answer: Avoid strategy, because the project is bringing the risk back within thresholds by removing high-risk elements of scope.
PMI Exam Traps
-
Trap: Confusing "avoid" at the overall project level with "avoid" for individual risks. Reality: Overall project avoid may involve canceling the entire project or removing major scope elements, not just avoiding a single risk event.
-
Trap: Thinking threshold modification is always wrong or indicates poor planning. Reality: Thresholds may be modified with key stakeholder agreement to embrace an opportunity—this is a valid exploit strategy.
-
Trap: Applying transfer/share only to negative risks. Reality: Transfer applies to negative overall risk; share applies to positive overall risk. Both involve third parties but with different objectives.
-
Trap: Confusing mitigate/enhance with avoid/exploit. Reality: Mitigate/enhance change the level of risk to optimize chances; avoid/exploit are more extreme and bring the project back within thresholds or capture exceptional opportunities.
Important PMI Connections
| Related Concept | Relationship Type | Exam Attention Point |
|---|---|---|
| Individual Project Risks | Component of | Overall project risk combines individual risks plus other sources of uncertainty |
| Risk Management Plan | Contains | Stakeholder risk appetite and measurable risk thresholds for overall project risk |
| Plan Risk Management | Process | Records risk appetites and defines thresholds that determine acceptable overall risk exposure |
| Stakeholder Engagement | Key Input | Stakeholder agreement is required to modify risk thresholds for embracing opportunities |
Quick Review Questions
-
What is the difference between "transfer" and "share" strategies for overall project risk, and when is each used?
-
A project has significantly positive overall risk outside agreed-upon thresholds. What two strategies could be adopted?
-
Where are stakeholder risk appetites recorded, and how do they relate to overall project risk thresholds?
-
What is the most extreme degree of risk avoidance, and when should it be used?
-
Under what circumstances may risk thresholds be modified with key stakeholder agreement?
PMBOK v8 Reference
Section 11.3 - Plan Risk Management (stakeholder risk appetite and thresholds) Section 11.5 - Plan Risk Responses (overall project risk strategies: avoid, exploit, transfer/share, mitigate/enhance)